Peas Out Mama

blogging about life in the mama 'hood

Book Review: Goodnight Moon

Goodnight Moon by Margaret Wise Brown: 3.5 stars

Goodnight Moon

I’m pretty sure I’ll incite the wrath of folks everywhere with my rating, but hear me out. I appreciate the concept—saying good night to all the things in one’s room. Pretty cute, right? Sure. The book also rhymes—nice touch. Also, our copy is perfect for gnawing. Major bonus (until it gets all wet and sloppy). I also respect that it’s a classic, a book every little kid must own. That’s why I bought it. It’s cute. It’s sweet. All cool.

But here’s what I don’t get: Why the fascination? I mean, first of all, this kid—oh right, it’s a bunny—this bunny’s room is freakin’ gigantic. There’s a fireplace even (roaring fire included). He might as well have a swimming pool in there to bid good night. And that bed is way too large for a bunny. I’m just sayin’.

Plus, there are some pretty odd items hanging out in that room. Why the drying rack with mittens? Why the random red balloon? And what’s up with the old lady whispering hush? Who is that chick? She’s just hanging out in a rocking chair. At first I thought she was a parent, but upon closer inspection, she appears to be more grandmotherly. But why refer to her as an old lady? Ageists. And need I mention the creepiness factor there? I don’t even get the impression that the bunny was being loud; cut him some slack. And what the hell is a bowl of mush doing in there? If my kid learns that it’s acceptable to keep old bowls of cereal in his room, I am totally blaming this book.

I have to give the author major kudos, however, for her brilliance. My favorite page is the blank one that says (no joke) Goodnight nobody. Really? Really? If I wrote a children’s book sans illustration on one page, I’d be deemed amateur, I’m sure. I can only imagine the publishers’ raised eyebrows. Can we get away with a blank page? Oh, did they ever. Straight to the bank, baby. And therein lies the brilliance.


Single Post Navigation

4 thoughts on “Book Review: Goodnight Moon

  1. I have read this every night for the past 2 years and while I love the book, my issues, other than the aforementioned, are as follows:

    1) Spoiled little bunny has a phone in his room. And it has a cord! How dangerous!

    2) The balloon, as said, has no business being there, especially with its incredibly long string…none too safe in a child’s room either

    3) What are those bears on chairs doing? Looks like a 12 step meeting to me. Probably not appropriate for a kids book.

    4) And that framed photo of the bears on chairs is located right over the bunny’s bed, so you know one night it will come crashing down on little bunny’s head, causing him years of trauma (and ironically also causing years of attendance at 12-step meetings, no doubt).

  2. Don’t forget the page where the mouse gets up on the nightstand next to the bowl of mush! Yes, I have read this many, many times.

  3. Bridget on said:

    Wyatt never liked this book. He tried to rip it up when he was about a year old. When he was a little older he said it scared him. He was never more specific about what it was that actually scared him though. I still have it someplace but don’t think I’ve ever read it to the youngest two!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: