Peas Out Mama

blogging about life in the mama 'hood

When a Good Story Hour Goes Bad

If you’re a loyal follower (and I have to assume you are), you’ve read my kiddie lit reviews. And because you have an amazing memory and my random musings take priority in your brain, you remember my thoughts on some of the…shall we say, um, weirdness in children’s books. Fine, if you don’t remember, click here for an example. Really, what is up with that old lady in the rocking chair?

Anyway, I read a hilarious blog post the other day that inspired me to raise this issue again. I recently befriended (literally, on facebook) mommy blogger Clare (a friend of Muffintop Mommy if you’ve been paying attention). Clare writes “it’s all good in the mother(hood).” You have to read her stuff — good, clean (well, mostly) fun. Click here to read Clare’s post called “You’re going on a BEAR Hunt? Dude. What’s up with that?” Her hilarious reflection on the children’s book We’re Going on a Bear Hunt will literally have you LOL. (Oh, and try to get past the fact that Clare has four children and looks like a twenty-year-old supermodel. No fairsies. Must be something in that Ohio water.)

Clare’s post conjured up a recent memory of story hour at the library. The “Mother Goose on the Loose” program (an early literacy program) is fantastic; Boo Boo loves it what with its songs, rhymes, books, and interactive approach. You should’ve seen him the day we read Good Night, Moon. You’d have thought a celebrity walked in the room. Pure bliss!

But two weeks ago, things turned dark with a nursery rhyme I’ve never heard before. Apparently I’m alone in this. I googled it and it seems to be a classic. Well, I’m glad my mom never sang it to us. I’d still be having nightmares.  Totally not the jumping on the bed monkeys. These monkeys are of the teasing variety. And boy, this rhyme has one message and one message only — you tease, you die. No really. If you’re not familiar with “Five Little Monkeys Swinging in a Tree,” you must click here to view. Even if you do know it, click anyway if only to see the crazy lady re-enact the whole thing to get the full effect. It’s worse with the puppets, right? Well, our librarian did the re-enactment, too (but with three monkeys…budget cuts). So imagine three little monkey puppets and one big alligator. Bad news. And if you know anything about my Boo, his best friend is a monkey. He’s stuffed and loved and Boo can’t sleep without him. In our family, you don’t mess with monkeys — even with teasing, obnoxious monkeys. I got pretty close to covering Boo’s eyes during the performance. Violent. Tragic. No one deserves such a fate.

And before I had time to get over the monkey incident, we moved on to the actual book of the day. Its title? Feathers for Lunch. This can’t be good. Basic plot: hungry cat tries to catch a bird to eat for lunch. Nice. Bird is fast. Bird gets away and cat gets feathers. What the hell, people? I can’t make this stuff up. And don’t be fooled by the picture on the cover. Oh sure, the bird escapes death, but this is not a nice story. Feathers for Lunch

Where are the nice stories? The happy stories? Surely more than one reference to death during a program designed for infants really isn’t appropriate. Am I wrong? I’m not trying to shelter my child. I’m just trying to keep him off the psychiatrist’s couch for another couple of years, ya know? So please, children’s writers and librarians of the world, help a sister out. Let’s make a pact. How ’bout we’ll keep reading to our kids and you keep the death/murder/nightmare-inducing themes to a minimum? At least until they’re four years old and can fully handle the weightiness of the issues, ‘kay? Deal?


Single Post Navigation

3 thoughts on “When a Good Story Hour Goes Bad

  1. muffintopmommy on said:

    I totally know the monkey book you’re talking about! Is it wrong that when I read it to the boys, I used my hands and made chomping sounds to illustrate the alligator? That one didn’t bug me so much but dude, as you well know, I do feel children’s literature is scarier than my underwear drawer and I have the essay to prove it. Pick up a book of fairy tales if you really want to lie awake at night….the only silver lining is that somehow, the boys seem unfazed thus far by the sketchy kid book plots! Fear not!

  2. Erin on said:

    Wow, I have never heard of this one. But I know that lady from her other YouTube kiddie videos, she freaks me out! I’m with you, not a fan of terrifying the kids through literature. But there is no escaping it, Walt Disney made a lot of money doing the same thing. He apparently had something against mother’s in general, they all are dead in his stories & replaced by wicked, jealous step-mothers. Anybody having a savings plan for their children’s future therapy?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: